By Stuart Bayens, Circulation/Audio - Visual, Stanley
A. Milner Library
"This film has been modified from its original version.It has been
formatted to fit your TV."We ’ve all seen this message at the start of a
videocassette,but what does it really mean?And what do Woody Allen and
Warren Beatty have to do with it being there?
When a movie is transferred from film to video, a number of technical
decisions have to be made. The first major hurdle is to accommodate the
difference between movie theatre and television screen shapes. When a
movie is presented in a theatre, the image is usually much wider than it
is tall. Television images are almost square. The shape and size of the
image is known as its "aspect ratio".
The aspect ratio for film images can vary between 1:1.6 (the image is
1.6 times wider than it is high) all the way up to 1:2.85 (this would be
an ultra-widescreen presentation). The aspect ratio for most TV screens is
1:1.33 (sometimes referred to as 4 by 3).
Traditionally, widescreen movies have been transferred to video using a
method called "pan & scan." Usually a technician not involved in the
artistic process is responsible for choosing the most important part of a
widescreen film image and centering that for the video transfer. When
action takes place on the sides of the movie image, the technician is
forced to move the video image around to follow it.
It is this "panning and scanning" that has upset film directors and
movie fans alike. The language of cinema relies heavily on elements such
as editing, lighting, camera angle and camera movement. By introducing
artificial camera movement in the pan & scan process, the artistic
integrity of the film is affected. In the early days of home video,
numerous directors refused to have their widescreen films released on
videocassette unless the entire image could be presented without
intervention. In addition to unintended camera movement, releasing a
widescreen film in the square video format meant chopping off the sides of
the picture. This would be like re-framing a print of "The Last Supper"
with a few disciples missing from each end of the table.
So, at the insistence of Woody Allen and others, most widescreen films
are now released on video in the "letterbox" format, with black horizontal
bars framing the video image to recreate the presentation in movie
theatres. (Newer model TV sets, especially those designed for home theatre
applications, are being manufactured to encompass the widescreen
dimensions).
Warren Beatty figures in this story because of the running time of his
194-minute 1981 film "Reds." The video distributors asked Mr. Beatty to
trim a few minutes off his film so it would more easily fit onto a
videocassette. Warren refused, citing artistic integrity.
As a result of the stand by these two directors, any film shown on TV
or released on video that is in a different form than its theatrical
presentation, must carry the "This film has been modified"
message.